Skip to content

Research & Insight

What we take with us

← Back to Library

What Holds Us Together? Issue 3

You can believe someone is being honest and still want to check that the work has been done. You can believe they care about you and still hesitate to put something important in their hands. Those positions can sound contradictory when we talk about trust as a single judgment. In an actual relationship, they can make perfect sense.

In last month’s What Holds Us Together?, I explored how an organization can follow its processes and still leave someone with an experience nobody intended. Each person does their part, but the person at the other end lives through the whole thing. My recent experience buying a vehicle brought another part of that question into focus. What, exactly, had that experience changed about my trust?

The financing had never been put in place. Incorrect contact information meant the finance team could not reach me. The salesperson heard nothing back and believed everything was proceeding. When I checked, he reassured me. Once the problem surfaced, people across the business stepped in, sorted it out and had everything ready for pickup. They also offered discounts I hadn’t requested. I would recommend them. But I will ask different questions next time.

One useful way of examining this comes from Roger Mayer, James Davis and David Schoorman’s research on trust. Their model distinguishes three judgments about someone’s trustworthiness. Ability concerns whether they have the skills to do what is needed. Benevolence concerns whether we believe they have our interests at heart. Integrity concerns whether they act according to principles we find acceptable, shown by consistency between what they say and what they do. These judgments are related, but they can differ.

Looking at my experience through those three questions helps explain why my response wasn’t simply that I trusted the business more or less. The way people stepped in gave me reason to believe they cared about my situation. The salesperson had also been straight with me about what he believed. I had no reason to conclude that he had deliberately misled me. Yet his reassurance had been wrong.

Ability was where the experience left me with two different judgments. I had seen that the people could resolve a difficult situation. I had also seen that the organization could believe everything was proceeding when an essential part of the work hadn’t happened. My confidence in the people’s ability to help had grown. My confidence that the process would catch a problem before I had to raise it had weakened.

That distinction seems important when we apply the model to an organization. Who, or what, are we trusting? The person helping us and the process behind them can give us different reasons to rely on them. A capable employee may earn our trust by overcoming a failure in the system. Their success can leave us grateful to them while uncertain about whether the organization can manage without that intervention. An excellent recovery demonstrates one kind of ability. It leaves the other less settled.

What changed was the work I would take on next time. I would ask for confirmation, check who had received it and make sure someone had verified the next step. I would still buy from them. But I would be doing some of the checking I had previously left to the organization. The story I carried forward was that they would help if something went wrong, but I needed to make sure nothing had been missed.

A customer stays, recommends the business and speaks highly of its people. From inside the organization, the relationship may look fully repaired. Meanwhile, the customer has learned to keep a closer watch. The next transaction succeeds partly because they are doing more to protect it. What looks like renewed confidence may include a private decision to leave less to chance.

This is why hearing someone describe their experience can reveal more than asking whether they were satisfied. Their account can show where confidence has not been fully restored, even when their overall opinion is positive.

It also changes the stories worth telling. A customer describing how kindly they were treated gives us something different from an account of a difficult job completed well. A leader explaining a decision that cost the business something may reveal how a principle holds up under pressure. When telling those stories, asking what happened, what was at stake and why a choice was made gives an audience more to consider than a general claim that a company can be trusted.

When people praise our employees, does that trust extend to the organization those people work within?

And if they continue doing business with us, what have they learned they must now check for themselves?


Research referenced:

Mayer, Davis and Schoorman, “An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust” (1995) https://doi.org/10.5465/AMR.1995.9508080335

← Back to Library