The uncertainty principle and psychology
“The uncertainty principle, it proves we can’t ever really know what’s going on. But even though you can’t figure anything out, you will be responsible for it on the midterm”.
— Larry Gopnik, A Serious Man (2009)
In 1973, a team of twenty clinical psychologists from Eastern Washington University began touring Air Force bases across the United States (Howard et al., 1979). Only a year prior, the Air Force’s Chief Master Sergeant, Richard D. Kisling, had lamented in a magazine interview that a lot of young airmen had “never had a serious conversation with an adult” (Bednarek, 2004, p. 79; Correll, 1972). The Force had little difficulty when it came to training its personnel in the technical aspects of their jobs, but fostering better communication and challenging dogmatic thinking had proved to be more difficult. That is the issue that the psychologists were there to help address. And to do this, they hosted workshops for the airmen.
The first session started with a quick questionnaire (Dogmatism Scale, n.d.) intended to gauge the airmen’s initial levels of dogmatism by asking them to rate how strongly they agreed or disagreed with statements such as,
“Once I get wound up in a heated discussion, I just can’t stop.”
and
“There are a number of people I have come to hate because of things they stand for.”
Throughout the remainder of 1973 and into 1974, the psychologists continued to lead the airmen through a series of lessons and structured exercises, role-playing different scenarios and exchanging feedback on one another’s communication. By all accounts, the workshop seemed to be going really well. But in order to measure exactly how well, the psychologists administered the dogmatism questionnaire once again at the end of their final session. The results that came back shocked them, and not in a good way. Contrary to the psychologists’ own subjective experience of how the workshop had gone, the data suggested that the airmen had actually become more dogmatic, not less. So what happened here?
To give you a hint, I will say right now that this article I am writing is not about dogmatism, nor is it about how to run an effective workshop. This article is about the act of measuring itself and how much we can really know anything about the world around us. And when it comes to conversations about the act of measuring, there is no better place to start than in the strange world of quantum physics.
In 1935, physicist Erwin Schrödinger, upset with how fellow physicist Niels Bohr had been interpreting his equations, challenged Bohr with an intentionally ridiculous thought-experiment about a box with a cat that is both alive and dead until someone opens up the lid and has a peek inside (Matthias, 2023). In the nine decades since, much ink has been spilled by physicists and New Age mystics alike, trying to explain how it is possible that the mere act of looking could possibly affect the things we are trying to see. The answer is far more mundane and yet also far more profound than one might be led to believe. Quantum physics is actually very normal, and many of the phenomena we typically associate with it show up in a wide variety of systems that we interact with everyday.
The observer effect made famous by Schrödinger’s cat is a great example. No matter what you are measuring, good measurements are only possible if the measuring device you use does not itself alter the object being measured. One cannot know if a cat is alive or dead if the mere act of looking changes that outcome, nor could one get accurate measurements from a ruler that magically shrinks everything it touches, nor from a thermometer that magically cools down cups of coffee. But the uncomfortable truth here is that most measurements actually do affect the object being measured. Putting a thermometer in a cup of coffee will cool the coffee down by approximately 0.14°C1 (a small enough margin that we typically ignore it). And even something as seemingly passive as looking involves bouncing light off an object’s surface and making sense of the light that bounces back into our eyes. Quantum physics is no different. But quantum physicists are saddled with a difficult task, because they are not studying the cats, they are studying light itself (and other photon-sized subatomic particles). Quantum physicists are therefore simply not afforded the luxury of ignoring the real-world impact that measuring all too often has. In this regard, the observer effect is not so much a marvel of physics as it is a marvel of physicists themselves and the awareness that they exercise in the work that they do.
The human mind is as fickle as any subatomic particle, and the observer effect is but one of at least seven different problems of measurement that researchers have often failed to account for when studying human behaviour (Dent, 2013; Henrich et al., 2010). Surveys, questionnaires, and invitations to reflect do more than simply measure human experience, they shape it as well. For instance, a recent study from the HUN-REN Centre for Social Sciences in Budapest found that typically, around 43% of Hungarians will tell you that they are satisfied with democracy. But begin that same survey with questions about the economy, and their satisfaction with democracy suddenly drops by 9%, despite the fact that they are answering the exact same set of questions (Papp et al., 2024). In another study, students at the University of Virginia were shown five different posters and asked to rate them. For anyone in advertising or design, this might seem like a fairly routine exercise. And there’s an obvious follow-up question here: why did people prefer one design over another? Some (but not all) of the participants in this study were indeed asked to explain their preferences. But rather than providing greater insight into their answers, this simple question actually changed how the participants responded to other questions and ultimately lowered the quality of their choices2 (Wilson et al., 1993).
So what happened with the airmen? Why did the data show that they had become more dogmatic?
To better understand the results, the Eastern Washington University psychologists returned to the Air Force bases and interviewed some of the airmen who had participated in their workshops. What they often found was that the airmen had in fact become less dogmatic, contrary to what the raw data suggested. What had changed, however, was the airmen’s perception of how dogmatic they had been to begin with, saying things like,
“I’d have put +3 (I agree very much) the first time I filled this out. But the group really opened my eyes and helped me to try to be more of an active listener and so while I still sometimes forget to listen to people, overall I’m not doing nearly so badly now. I’ll put -1 (I disagree a little).”
These results changed how psychologists typically measure the effectiveness workshops like the one described, however it did not end the debate (Nimon et al., 2011). Because the fact of the matter is that humans are inherently very hard to measure, and there is no perfect way to do it.
So when certainty is out of reach, how can we ensure that our understanding comes as close to the truth as possible?
1 Assuming a 250mL cup of coffee at 80°C and a 5g steel probe dipped half way in at 22°C.
2 Based on a three-week follow-up.
References
Bednarek, J. R. (2004). Generations of Chevrons: A History of the Enlisted Force. United States Air Force. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GOVPUB-D301-PURL-gpo11124/pdf/GOVPUB-D301-PURL-gpo11124.pdf
Coen, J., & Coen, E. (Directors). (2009). A Serious Man. Focus Features.
Correll, J. T. (1972, January). The GI’s Man in Washington. Air Force Magazine, 55(1), 52–55. https://www.airandspaceforces.com/app/uploads/2024/09/AFmag_1972_01.pdf
Dent, E. (2013). The Observation, Inquiry, and Measurement Challenges Surfaced by Complexity Theory (SSRN Scholarly Paper №2335850). Social Science Research Network. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2335850
Dogmatism Scale. (n.d.). Retrieved November 12, 2026, from https://psytests.org/classic/dscaleen.html
Henrich, J., Heine, S. J., & Norenzayan, A. (2010). The weirdest people in the world? The Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 33(2–3), 61–83; discussion 83–135. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X0999152X
Howard, G. S., Ralph, K. M., Gulanick, N. A., Maxwell, S. E., Nance, D. W., & Gerber, S. K. (1979). Internal Invalidity in Pretest-Posttest Self-Report Evaluations and a Re-evaluation of Retrospective Pretests. Applied Psychological Measurement, 3(1), 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1177/014662167900300101
Matthias, M. (2023). Schrodinger’s cat. In Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/science/Schrodingers-cat
Nimon, K., Zigarmi, D., & Allen, J. (2011). Measures of Program Effectiveness Based on Retrospective Pretest Data: Are All Created Equal? American Journal of Evaluation, 32(1), 8–28. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098214010378354
Papp, Z., Susánszky, P., & Szabó, A. (2024). Question-Order Effect in the Study of Satisfaction with Democracy: Lessons from Three Split-Ballot Experiments. Sociological Methodology, 54(2), 404–417. https://doi.org/10.1177/00811750241254363
Wilson, T. D., Lisle, D. J., Schooler, J. W., Hodges, S. D., Klaaren, K. J., & LaFleur, S. J. (1993). Introspecting about Reasons can Reduce Post-Choice Satisfaction. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 19(3), 331–339. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167293193010

